Case Study
5 min read

Do Overlapping LSA Service Areas Hurt Leads? A 3-Month Test

Published on
Overlapping Google LSA service areas test: leads fell 28% with overlap off

Industry: Residential roofing, multi-location · Channel: Google Local Services Ads · Test: March to May, three months

Do overlapping Local Services Ads service areas make your own profiles compete with each other? We turned the overlaps off for a month to find out. Every number went the wrong way.

The question

A multi-location roofer ran several Local Services Ads profiles whose service areas overlapped. The worry was simple: if two profiles target the same towns, maybe they bid against each other and push each other's costs up. So we ran a three-month test: overlaps on, overlaps off, overlaps back on.

Google's own help page explains why the answer wasn't obvious. LSA rankings are based on your bid, how likely your ad is to produce a lead, and your profile quality: rating, review count, response time and verification. Service area overlap is not on the list.

Three months

Bar chart: 331 leads in March with overlaps, 238 in April without, 341 in May with overlaps back; cost per lead 43.26, 48.50 and 53.42 dollars
Leads fell when the overlaps came out and recovered when they went back in.
March
(overlaps on)
April
(overlaps off)
May
(overlaps back on)
Spend$14,319.94$11,542.91 (down 19%)$18,214.52 (up 58%)
Charged leads331238 (down 28%)341 (up 43%)
Cost per lead$43.26$48.50 (up 12%)$53.42 (up 10%)
Grouped bars: branch 1 144 to 105 leads, branch 2 84 to 24, branch 3 36 to 30 when overlaps were removed
Every branch lost leads with the overlaps removed. Branch 2 lost 71%.

When overlaps came back in May, Branch 2 went from 24 leads to 94, Branch 3 from 30 to 48 and Branch 1 from 105 to 116.

What it tells us

Removing overlaps didn't help any profile. Each one got fewer leads at a higher cost, so the overlaps weren't cannibalising each other in any way we could measure. We kept the overlaps the LSA platform suggested.

What we can't claim

  • Cost per lead kept rising in May. At $53.42 it was 24% above March, even with the overlaps back. Spend went up 58% that month, which makes May a different test, not a clean reversal.
  • Three months is three data points. Seasonal demand for roofing changes from March to May, and we can't separate that from the overlap change.
  • One company, one market set. This is a test on one multi-location roofer's account, not a rule for every LSA account.

Running Local Services Ads across several locations?

Talk to us. We tested this on a live account before recommending anything to clients.

Request your SEO audit · Call (434) 423-5144

‍

related case studies

Ready to write your own success story?

Start with an SEO Audit - your roadmap to clear visibility and measurable growth.